Why I ditched my Blackberry Curve for an iPhone 3GS
I have been a long time Blackberry fan, and even wrote Beyond411, a popular local search application for the Blackberry. But with the release of the iPhone 3GS, I finally reach my personal tipping point and bought an iPhone.
My story is a common one; AppleInseder reports that 12% of early iPhone 3GS buyers are Blackberry owners
Here are some the factors that pushed me to get an iPhone.
- The overwhelming momentum of Apple’s app store: Apple’s position in mobile apps is similar to what Microsoft enjoyed with Windows; I don’t believe RIM or any one else can catch up even if they match or exceed Apple’s features. There are a number of iPhone apps that I (and my kids) find fun and compelling.
- Poor developer support from RIM: My primary interaction with Blackberry developer support was when they forced me to change the name of Berry411 to Beyond411, part of their trademark enforcement of anything related to Black or Berry. Other than their friendly trademark police, I was disappointed at how little RIM had to offer to third party developers. They wanted a $2000 fee just to join their developer program, offered limited promotional opportunities, and seemed to subservient to the wishes of their carrier partners.
- OS Bugs and uncompetitive feature set: The Storm is no iPhone in terms of features or usability. Plus the OS has hanging bugs that don’t reproduce in the simulator; this makes my life as a developer miserable.
- Declining build quality: I can’t tell you how many Blackberry’s I’ve gone through. Gone are the tanks of old: as RIM has chased the consumer market, their phones have gotten cheaper and more fragile. The Curve I just replaced rebooted randomly; the two previous curves had broken USB connections, as did the 8800 before that. The Pearl style trackball is much more prone to gumming up than the jog wheel it replace. Recent keyboards are smaller and harder to type on than the older ones, again because of RIM’s wish to appeal to a broad audience.
In short, RIM is watering down the features that made it special, failing to keep up with the unique features of Apple and Palm, and losing the battle for the hearts and minds of developers.
I won’t pretend that there aren’t features I miss in the Blackberry. A virtual keyboard is no replacement a real one. Reading mail is definitely slower on the iPhone than the Blackberry– I have to wait several seconds the mail app to pull down new messages every time I launch it. For now I’m willing to live with these limitations in exchange for the other advantages. Blackberry could win me back, but it’s not easy to divide your loyalties between two phones.
Some Blackberry converts to the iPhone have asked me if I plan to create an iPhone version of Beyond411. Now that I’ve got one myself, that’s looking a lot more likely.
5 Comments so far
Leave a comment
Welcome to the fold! It’s not all peaches and cream over here in iPhone-land; notably, Apple’s level of touch and support for retail customers is in many respects much better than what they offer developers (which seems pretty broken, IMHO), but indeed, it’s hard to argue with the platform’s momentum!
i411?
By maiken on 06.22.09 6:49 pm
[…] Why I ditched my Blackberry Curve for an iPhone 3GS – with the 3Gs, I’m getting tempted to make the switch as well. […]
By Around the web | alexking.org on 06.28.09 1:28 pm
[…] One other thing that really effected my decision was Phil Bogle’s decision to switch from BlackBerry to the iPhone 3G S. For those of you not familiar with Phil, he created one of the most popular and useful BlackBerry applications of all-time. Beyond411 (formerly Berry411). When you start to see long-term hardcore BB developers abandoning ship, it might be time to rethink your decision to stand by RIM. […]
By iPhone 3G S: In the end it was the only decision on 06.30.09 10:59 pm
the blackberry curve is nothing compared to the iphone in my opinon. its way to glitchy and it really irritates me
By okkkk3 on 10.08.09 2:31 pm
The pearl was my first smart phone, and the expirence was aweseome thanks mostly to berry 411. And after getting an iPhone 3g when they first came out, I’ve yet to see any app that’s as accurate, easy to use, and clutter free as berry 411 was. Of you make an iPhone app, please keep these features. It’s just amazing that you could do anything from find pizza, and add them to a contact and get a definition of a word just immediatly. Can I sign up to be notified for a release?
By Viktor on 11.12.09 11:22 am
Leave a comment